Your choice of a financial advisor can impact your financial future just as much as your investments do. Financial planning is not only centered around your investment returns but also trust and peace of mind. The right financial advisor should feel like the perfect fit. Their guidance should make your financial journey smoother, not stressful.
One big question many people face is whether to go with an independent financial advisor or one tied to a firm. This article can help you understand what an independent financial advisor brings to the table so you can make the right choice if you are thinking of changing financial advisors or hiring a new one.
How do independent advisors impact financial planning?
1. They are more likely to offer genuine advice
Independent financial advisors have the freedom to put your needs first and offer genuine advice that addresses your concerns. They are not tied to a firm’s products or pressured to meet quotas for specific investments or insurance plans. There is no agenda to sell more of a particular product. They have more independence over recommendations, which allows them to offer advice that is truly centered on you and not their employer. Independent advisors essentially succeed when you do. An independent financial advisor is driven by your financial progress because their business depends on satisfied clients and referrals. They are not answerable to a corporate office. They are answering you. This structure naturally leads to advice that is more transparent, unbiased, and focused on your financial well-being.
Independent financial advisors can tailor their recommendations to fit your unique needs. On the other hand, when working with a firm-based advisor, their recommendations may be limited to what their company offers. That is not to say that firm-based advisors do not offer valuable financial advice. Many are skilled professionals who want to help their clients do so, irrespective of their employment status. However, their recommendations may be shaped by the firm’s policies, financial incentives, or limited investment options. With an independent financial advisor, you get the confidence of knowing that their guidance is based purely on what benefits you.
2. They are not forced to recommend specific products
Independent financial advisors are not restricted to a specific set of products. Unlike firm-based financial advisors, who often have to work within a limited selection of in-house investment funds or insurance plans, independent financial advisors have the freedom to explore a wider range of options. Firm-based advisors may be under pressure to promote certain products, either because they align with the company’s business strategy or because they bring in higher commissions. In some cases, they may not even be allowed to suggest investments or policies from outside providers, especially if those options come from competing firms. That kind of limitation can prevent you from accessing better-performing or lower-cost alternatives.
An independent advisor, on the other hand, has no such constraints. Their job is not just to sell a product but also to help you reach your financial goals. If a particular investment or insurance plan is the best fit for you, they can recommend it without worrying about whether it benefits the parent company. An independent financial advisor can weigh all available options rather than just a select few. As a result, you are far more likely to end up with a financial plan that truly works for you.
For example, if their firm has a preferred Individual Retirement Account (IRA), that is likely what they will suggest, even if there is a better option in the market. However, an independent financial advisor can compare multiple providers and find the best IRA for you, not just the best one available through a single firm. They have more flexibility when it comes to comparing products and market research, which helps you get access to better products for investment diversification.
3. They are more likely to form long-term relationships
Independent financial advisors are more likely to build long-term relationships with their clients. Since many of them own their businesses or work as part of smaller firms, they tend to have fewer clients and can offer a more personalized approach to financial planning. They are not employees of a larger company. Instead, they are invested in the success of their practice, which drives them to maintain lasting relationships with their clients.
Firm-based financial advisors may move between teams or even companies as they advance in their careers. If your financial advisor leaves for a new role, you may find yourself assigned to someone else at the firm who does not know your financial history or long-term goals. This can disrupt your financial planning and force you to start over with someone new. The structure of larger firms also makes personalized service more difficult. Financial advisors in these settings may be working with multiple clients at the same time, which can limit the amount of time they can dedicate to each individual. Instead of truly getting to know your financial situation, they may follow a standardized process that may or may not address your specific needs.
An independent advisor, however, has more control over how they work with clients. They can take the time to understand your financial goals. Because they are not constantly moving up the corporate ladder or being reassigned, you can count on working with the same person year after year. A long-term relationship with your financial advisor can make a significant difference to your financial success. When your financial advisor knows you well, they are more familiar with your investment preferences, risk tolerance, liabilities, and general financial expectations. This can help you navigate major life events with greater ease and financial adequacy.
Things to look for in an independent financial advisor
1. Check for fiduciary duty and registration
One of the first things to check is whether the advisor has a fiduciary duty. A fiduciary financial advisor is legally expected to act in your best interest. This ensures that their recommendations are based solely on what is good for you. While many independent financial advisors are fiduciaries, it is not a guarantee, so confirming this upfront is essential. You must also check if the financial advisor is registered. Firm-based financial advisors must be registered as part of their employment, but independent advisors operate on their own, making it your responsibility to verify their credentials. A qualified independent advisor should be registered with the Securities and Exchange Commission (SEC) or with a state regulatory authority.
2. Confirm if they are truly independent
Not every financial advisor who claims to be independent actually operates with full independence. A professional who is going independent as a financial advisor may leave large firms and move to smaller ones while still earning commissions from selling investment products. Others may establish their own Registered Investment Advisory (RIA) firm, which holds them to a higher fiduciary standard and allows them to provide fee-based advice. Understanding the difference between these is essential in ensuring you are working with someone who truly prioritizes your financial well-being.
One way to understand if your financial advisor works independently is to check how they are compensated. Independent broker-dealers may not manufacture their own investment products, but their primary business is still selling them. So, their recommendations could be influenced by commissions. A true independent financial advisor, particularly one registered as an RIA, has fewer conflicts of interest and can provide fee-based financial planning without the pressure to push specific products. If you are considering working with a financial advisor who has recently left a firm to go independent, take the time to evaluate their transition. Instead of simply asking whether they are independent, you may need to dig deeper. In this case, you must check their career history. You must know if they have changed advisory firms frequently in the past decade. This can help you understand their career stability and whether their moves were motivated by better client service or financial incentives. You must also ask about the financial incentives they receive, if any. Some financial advisors may receive bonuses for switching firms. If a move was tied to a large financial gain, it could influence the way they structure their fees or the products they recommend. You must also check if the financial advisor will be able to offer the same level of financial planning, portfolio management, and ongoing support at their new firm.
Moving to a new firm can sometimes bring changes in a financial advisor’s pricing structure, too. Ask them if their fees are now higher, lower, or structured differently than before. Also, make sure you understand what you will be paying and what you are getting in return. Some independent firms still allow financial advisors to sell commission-based investment or insurance products. If that is the case, ask whether their commission rates have changed and whether their new structure creates any potential conflicts of interest. Another thing to check if a financial advisor has recently gone independent is if their previous firm has placed restrictions on taking clients with them. This can help you decide if you want to continue working with them.
3. Understand their working structure
When choosing an independent financial advisor, it is important to understand how they operate. Their investment selection process, transparency, and client workload can all impact the quality of advice you receive. Start by looking at how they choose investment products. It is important to select a financial advisor with a clear and transparent process for evaluating different options. You can ask them about their selection criteria and how they evaluate costs, long-term growth, and risk. Make sure to select a financial advisor who openly explains their decision-making process, as this establishes trust and transparency.
Next, you must consider how many clients they manage. One of the benefits of working with an independent financial advisor is personalized attention, but if they take on too many clients, they may struggle to give you the time you deserve. You can ask them how often they meet with clients, how accessible they are for questions, and whether they provide ongoing portfolio reviews. It is essential for your financial advisor to be available when you need them, not just during scheduled check-ins.
Independent vs. firm-based financial advisors – what should you choose?
Independent financial advisors typically offer greater flexibility and personalized advice. They are not tied to any single company’s products and tend to build long-term relationships with clients with ongoing financial planning. Firm-based advisors, on the other hand, can still provide valuable direction, especially if you are looking for specific financial products offered by their firm. They may have access to certain investment opportunities, but their recommendations could be limited to the products their company approves or sells.
Before deciding, take the time to ask about the financial advisor’s status. Make sure to check if they are truly independent or affiliated with a broker-dealer that still influences their recommendations.
To conclude
Are independent financial advisors worth it? Absolutely. They offer unbiased financial advice, greater transparency, and personalized attention. Since they are not tied to a specific firm’s products, their recommendations are typically more aligned with your financial goals. That said, not all independent financial advisors are the same. Verifying their credentials is crucial. Ideally, they should be properly registered and operate as fiduciaries so that they act in your best interest. Checking their experience, regulatory status, and other similar details can help you find a suitable financial partner.
Use WiserAdvisor’s free advisor match tool to get matched with seasoned financial advisors who can help create a personalized finalized plan and guide you on how to achieve your financial goals and objectives. Answer a few simple questions and get matched with 2 to 3 vetted financial advisors based on your requirements.
